Contents
Introduction
When you find yourself without brown sugar while baking or cooking, don’t panic! There are plenty of alternatives out there that can totally save your recipe. You might be wondering, what can I use in place of brown sugar? Well, in this article, we’ll dive deep into some awesome substitutes. Plus, we’ll cover why they work and how to use them right, ensuring your culinary adventures remain flavorful and fun!
General Substitutes for Brown Sugar

Finding replacements is way easier than it sounds. Think of it this way: Brown sugar can simply be swapped out for other sweeteners that provide similar flavors or textures. Plus, sometimes we just need to get a bit creative! The key is understanding what each substitute will bring to the table—literally.
Common Substitutes

Granulated Sugar + Molasses
Hands down, one of the best substitutes for brown sugar is granulated sugar mixed with molasses. They basically create a version of brown sugar and are super easy to whip up. To mimic light brown sugar, mix 1 cup of granulated sugar with 1 tablespoon of molasses. For that dark brown sugar vibe, just increase it to 2 tablespoons. You’ll get a similar flavor and moisture. If you’re curious about ratios, this combo is incredibly common—it almost feels like a no-brainer!
Coconut Sugar
If you’re looking for something that’s more on the natural side, coconut sugar is a fantastic option. It has a caramel-like taste and works as a great 1:1 replacement for brown sugar. Plus, it’s lower on the glycemic index, which is a win for those who are health-conscious!
Honey or Maple Syrup
Honey and maple syrup are both liquid gold when it comes to sweetening. However, remember they can change the texture of your recipe. For every cup of brown sugar, use about ¾ cup of liquid sweetener and reduce other liquids in the recipe slightly. For example, when baking cookies, utilizing honey might give your cookies a doughy texture—but hey, those chewy vibes aren’t always bad!
Agave Nectar
Another sweet contender is agave nectar. It’s sweeter than brown sugar, so you may want to use less of it—like around ⅔ cup in place of a full cup of brown sugar. Just be aware that it has a distinct flavor and may affect the final dish’s texture. Yet, it can totally work in recipes where the sweetness level is pivotal!
Unique Suggestions from Reddit Users
Sometimes the best suggestions come from fellow home cooks. Reddit users have shared gems like using date sugar and even applesauce. While date sugar won’t add moisture, it will definitely give you some unique flavors that can elevate your dessert game! Meanwhile, applesauce is often a go-to for those looking to add natural sweetness and moisture—especially in healthy baking. Just remember, it can make baked goods denser.
Recommendations for Substitution
When considering what can I use in place of brown sugar, the choice largely depends on the specific recipe you’re tackling. For heavy hitters like brownies or cookies, I recommend sticking to granulated sugar plus molasses for that gooey texture. But for lighter pastries or glazed dishes, honey or maple syrup might be your best bet. Read through your recipe carefully and think about what flavors you want to emphasize!
Conclusion
Thanks for hanging out with me, Tim Byres, while we explored what can I use in place of brown sugar. If you’ve enjoyed this or have any personal experiences with substitutes, drop a comment below! You can also check out more delicious recipes and tips at Smokerestaurant.com. Happy cooking!